Growth requirement for methionine in human melanoma-derived cell lines with different levels of MMACHC expression and methylation

Methionine dependence, the inability to grow in culture when methionine in the medium is replaced by its metabolic precursor homocysteine, occurs in many tumor cell lines. In most affected lines, the cause of methionine dependence is not known. An exception is the melanoma-derived cell line MeWo-LC1, in which hypermethylation of the MMACHC gene is associated with decreased MMACHC expression. Decreased expression results in decreased provision of the methylcobalamin cofactor required for activity of methionine synthase and thus decreased conversion of homocysteine to methionine. Analysis of data in the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia Archive demonstrated that MMACHC hypermethylation and decreased MMACHC expression occurred more frequently in melanoma cell lines when compared to other tumor cell lines. We further investigated methionine dependence and aspects of MMACHC function in a panel of six melanoma lines, including both melanoma lines with known methionine dependence status (MeWo, which is methionine independent, and A375, which is methionine dependent). We found that the previously unclassified melanoma lines HMCB, Colo829 and SH-4 were methionine dependent, while SK-Mel-28 was methionine independent. However, despite varying levels of MMACHC methylation and expression, none of the tested lines had decreased methylcobalamin and adenosylcobalamin synthesis as seen in MeWo-LC1, and the functions of both cobalamin-dependent enzymes methionine synthase and methylmalonyl-CoA mutase were intact. Thus, while melanoma lines were characterized by relatively high levels of MMACHC methylation and low expression, the defect in metabolism observed in MeWo-LC1 was unique, and decreased MMACHC expression was not a cause of methionine dependence in the other melanoma lines.