An Interlaboratory Study to Identify Potential Visible Protein-Like Particle Standards

Visible protein-like particle standards may improve visual inspection and/or appearance testing practices used in the biotechnology industry. They may improve assay performance resulting in better alignment and more standardized training among different companies. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has conducted an interlaboratory study to test whether the standards under development mimic typical proteinaceous particles found in biotherapeutics and if they can be implemented during the visual inspection process. Fourteen organizations from industry and government have participated. A total of 20 labs from these 14 organizations participated with analysts from 6 formulation, 7 analytical, 4 quality control, and 3 manufacturing labs. The circulated samples consisted of abraded ethylene tetrafluoroethylene (ETFE) particles or photolithographic particles. The results consist of qualitative ratings, which varied substantially among organizations and within labs. Polydisperse ETFE particle suspensions, containing particles enriched in greater than 150 µm in size, were rated more favorably than the photolithographic particles by formulation and analytical scientists. The largest monodisperse photolithographic particles (approximately 300 µm in size) were favored equally compared to ETFE by all scientists. Solution modifications to decrease the settling rate or to alter optical properties of the ETFE solutions yielded lower ratings by the analysts. Both particle types received mixed ratings for their usability and for their application for visual inspection and for training purposes. Industry feedback will assist NIST in developing reference material(s) for visible protein-like particles. Graphical Abstract