Conservative treatment for stable osteochondritis dissecans of the elbow before epiphyseal closure: effectiveness of elbow immobilization for healing

Stable lesions of osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the capitellum have been treated with activity restriction (AR), and the complete healing requires 1 or 2 years. Little is known about the effectiveness of elbow immobilization. We hypothesized that elbow immobilization would have positive effects on healing of stable OCD. The study subjects were 43 patients (mean age: 12.2 years) with 43 stable OCD lesions of the prematured elbow (mean skeletal age score: 17.1 points of 0-27 points system). The subjects were divided into 3 groups: group A, AR without elbow immobilization, 22 cases; group B, splint (mean: 8.8 weeks) followed by AR, 9 cases; and group C, cast (mean: 3.7 weeks) followed by splint (mean: 7.3 weeks) and AR, 12 cases. The mean nonoperative observation period was 17.5 months (minimum three months). On anteroposterior radiographs of the elbow at 45 degrees of flexion, 5 observers independently assessed the healing of the capitellum, and the interobserver and intraobserver reliabilities were examined. The differences in outcomes among 3 groups were also examined. The interobserver and intraobserver reliabilities of the radiographic assessment were almost perfect (Cohen kappa value: 0.82 and 0.91, respectively). There were no significant differences in age, sports played, or stage of the lesion before the treatment. The proportion of patients returning to sports and the mean period required were 77% and 8.2 months in group A, 78% and 5.7 months in group B, and 83% and 4.4 months in group C, respectively. The proportion of patients showing ossification in the central aspect of the capitellum and the mean period required were 67% and 8.2 months in group A, 63% and 4.9 months in group B, and 91% and 1.9 months in group C, respectively. The proportion of patients showing complete healing and the mean period required were 41% and 16.4 months in group A, 67% and 7.0 months in group B, and 92% and 5.5 months in group C, respectively. Compared to group A, group C showed a significantly earlier return to sports (P = .034), a significantly shorter period required for ossification (P