Screening rough-seeded lupins (Lupinus pilosus Murr. and Lupinus atlanticus Glads.) for tolerance to calcareous soils

Soil- and solution-based screening methods were used to identify interspecific and intraspecific variation in lupins for tolerance to calcareous soils. Plants were grown for 21 days in a calcareous soil (pH 8.2; 50% CaCO3; moisture content 90% of field capacity) for soil-based screening and in nutrient solution containing 15 mM KHCO3 for solution-based screening. Chlorosis as an indicator of tolerance was recorded. Lupinus pilosus Murr. had the most tolerant genotypes and had the greatest range of intraspecific variation. Most genotypes of Lupinus atlanticus Glads. and Lupinus angustifolius L. were moderately intolerant, although two genotypes of L. atlanticus appeared to be tolerant. Lupinus albus L. had moderately tolerant to moderately intolerant genotypes, whilst the single genotypes of Lupinus cosentinii Guss. and Lupinus digitatus Forsk. appeared tolerant. In a field study six genotypes of L. pilosus identified in the soil-based screening as differing in their tolerance to the calcareous soil were grown on comparable calcareous (pH ∼8.3; topsoil 3% CaCO3, subsoil 13% CaCO3) and non-calcareous (pH ∼7.3) soils within a paddock. Chlorosis and nutrient concentrations in the youngest leaves were measured 53 days after sowing, whilst grain yield was estimated at harvest. Despite the soil containing a much lower CaCO3 content than used in the screening method, the field study confirmed that moderately intolerant to intolerant genotypes had lower relative grain yields than more tolerant genotypes. Chlorosis rankings of the genotypes were correlated between field and the screening studies. It is suggested that the incorporation of genes conferring tolerance to calcareous soils into high yielding, agronomically suitable genotypes of L. pilosus should be an important objective in a lupin breeding program for calcareous soils.