A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish
The article ‘In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world’ by Kagan et al. triggered a wave of positive mainstream and scientific media coverage as well as a widespread negative reaction from the scientific community. Here, we discuss why this negative reactio...
Gespeichert in:
| Veröffentlicht in: | Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.) Mass.), 2023-03, Vol.111 (5), p.604-605 |
|---|---|
| Hauptverfasser: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
| Format: | Artikel |
| Sprache: | eng |
| Schlagworte: | |
| Online-Zugang: | Volltext |
| Tags: |
Tag hinzufügen
Keine Tags, Fügen Sie den ersten Tag hinzu!
|
| container_end_page | 605 |
|---|---|
| container_issue | 5 |
| container_start_page | 604 |
| container_title | Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.) |
| container_volume | 111 |
| creator | Balci, Fuat Ben Hamed, Suliann Boraud, Thomas Bouret, Sébastien Brochier, Thomas Brun, Cédric Cohen, Jeremiah Y. Coutureau, Etienne Deffains, Marc Doyère, Valérie Gregoriou, Georgia G. Heimel, J. Alexander Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth Lee, Daeyeol Leuthardt, Eric C. Mainen, Zachary F. Mathis, Mackenzie Monosov, Ilya E. Naudé, Jérémie Orsborn, Amy L. Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo Procyk, Emmanuel Sabatini, Bernardo Sallet, Jérôme Sandi, Carmen Schall, Jeffrey D. Soltani, Alireza Svoboda, Karel Wilson, Charles R.E. Zimmermann, Jan |
| description | The article ‘In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world’ by Kagan et al. triggered a wave of positive mainstream and scientific media coverage as well as a widespread negative reaction from the scientific community. Here, we discuss why this negative reaction is legitimate and must be taken seriously. We raise concerns about the key claim of the article: that it demonstrates that “a single layer of in vitro cortical neurons can self-organize activity to display intelligent and sentient behavior when embodied in a simulated game-world”. |
| doi_str_mv | 10.1016/j.neuron.2023.02.009 |
| format | Article |
| fullrecord | <record><control><sourceid>proquest_hal_p</sourceid><recordid>TN_cdi_hal_primary_oai_HAL_hal_04012408v1</recordid><sourceformat>XML</sourceformat><sourcesystem>PC</sourcesystem><els_id>S0896627323001137</els_id><sourcerecordid>2783492883</sourcerecordid><originalsourceid>FETCH-LOGICAL-c442t-136d2805a356016b747c61333f3c26a839c50bd8439a72509c8666c6a6d6f0a43</originalsourceid><addsrcrecordid>eNp9kEtLxDAQgIMouj7-gUiOemidPJomF2GR9QELXvQcsmmqWdpmTbqC_96sVY-e5sE3M8yH0DmBkgAR1-tycNsYhpICZSXQEkDtoRkBVRecKLWPZiCVKASt2RE6TmkNQHilyCE6YkIKxoiaocUcR5c2YUgOjwHbzvg-4dBi17v46oYR-2F0Xedzbh02Q4NT7vrvyg_Y4Mant1N00JouubOfeIJe7hbPtw_F8un-8Xa-LCzndCwIEw2VUBlWifzCqua1FYQx1jJLhZFM2QpWjeRMmZpWoKwUQlhhRCNaMJydoKtp75vp9Cb63sRPHYzXD_Ol3vWAA6Ec5AfJ7OXEbmJ437o06t4nm18xgwvbpGktGVdUSpZRPqE2hpSia_92E9A72XqtJ9l6J1sD1Vl2Hrv4ubBd9a75G_q1m4GbCXDZyYd3USf7ba7x0dlRN8H_f-ELGpqPMQ</addsrcrecordid><sourcetype>Open Access Repository</sourcetype><iscdi>true</iscdi><recordtype>article</recordtype><pqid>2783492883</pqid></control><display><type>article</type><title>A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish</title><source>Cell Press Free Archives</source><source>Elsevier ScienceDirect Journals</source><source>Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek - Frei zugängliche E-Journals</source><creator>Balci, Fuat ; Ben Hamed, Suliann ; Boraud, Thomas ; Bouret, Sébastien ; Brochier, Thomas ; Brun, Cédric ; Cohen, Jeremiah Y. ; Coutureau, Etienne ; Deffains, Marc ; Doyère, Valérie ; Gregoriou, Georgia G. ; Heimel, J. Alexander ; Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth ; Lee, Daeyeol ; Leuthardt, Eric C. ; Mainen, Zachary F. ; Mathis, Mackenzie ; Monosov, Ilya E. ; Naudé, Jérémie ; Orsborn, Amy L. ; Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo ; Procyk, Emmanuel ; Sabatini, Bernardo ; Sallet, Jérôme ; Sandi, Carmen ; Schall, Jeffrey D. ; Soltani, Alireza ; Svoboda, Karel ; Wilson, Charles R.E. ; Zimmermann, Jan</creator><creatorcontrib>Balci, Fuat ; Ben Hamed, Suliann ; Boraud, Thomas ; Bouret, Sébastien ; Brochier, Thomas ; Brun, Cédric ; Cohen, Jeremiah Y. ; Coutureau, Etienne ; Deffains, Marc ; Doyère, Valérie ; Gregoriou, Georgia G. ; Heimel, J. Alexander ; Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth ; Lee, Daeyeol ; Leuthardt, Eric C. ; Mainen, Zachary F. ; Mathis, Mackenzie ; Monosov, Ilya E. ; Naudé, Jérémie ; Orsborn, Amy L. ; Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo ; Procyk, Emmanuel ; Sabatini, Bernardo ; Sallet, Jérôme ; Sandi, Carmen ; Schall, Jeffrey D. ; Soltani, Alireza ; Svoboda, Karel ; Wilson, Charles R.E. ; Zimmermann, Jan</creatorcontrib><description>The article ‘In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world’ by Kagan et al. triggered a wave of positive mainstream and scientific media coverage as well as a widespread negative reaction from the scientific community. Here, we discuss why this negative reaction is legitimate and must be taken seriously. We raise concerns about the key claim of the article: that it demonstrates that “a single layer of in vitro cortical neurons can self-organize activity to display intelligent and sentient behavior when embodied in a simulated game-world”.</description><identifier>ISSN: 0896-6273</identifier><identifier>EISSN: 1097-4199</identifier><identifier>DOI: 10.1016/j.neuron.2023.02.009</identifier><identifier>PMID: 36863319</identifier><language>eng</language><publisher>United States: Elsevier Inc</publisher><subject>Cognitive science ; Neuroscience</subject><ispartof>Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.), 2023-03, Vol.111 (5), p.604-605</ispartof><rights>2023 Elsevier Inc.</rights><rights>Public Domain Mark</rights><lds50>peer_reviewed</lds50><oa>free_for_read</oa><woscitedreferencessubscribed>false</woscitedreferencessubscribed><citedby>FETCH-LOGICAL-c442t-136d2805a356016b747c61333f3c26a839c50bd8439a72509c8666c6a6d6f0a43</citedby><cites>FETCH-LOGICAL-c442t-136d2805a356016b747c61333f3c26a839c50bd8439a72509c8666c6a6d6f0a43</cites><orcidid>0000-0001-7486-4993 ; 0000-0003-0057-7929 ; 0000-0001-5781-6498 ; 0000-0001-6948-1234 ; 0000-0002-3851-669X ; 0000-0002-7878-0209 ; 0000-0001-9497-919X</orcidid></display><links><openurl>$$Topenurl_article</openurl><openurlfulltext>$$Topenurlfull_article</openurlfulltext><thumbnail>$$Tsyndetics_thumb_exl</thumbnail><linktohtml>$$Uhttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0896627323001137$$EHTML$$P50$$Gelsevier$$H</linktohtml><link.rule.ids>230,314,776,780,881,3537,27901,27902,65534</link.rule.ids><backlink>$$Uhttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36863319$$D View this record in MEDLINE/PubMed$$Hfree_for_read</backlink><backlink>$$Uhttps://hal.science/hal-04012408$$DView record in HAL$$Hfree_for_read</backlink></links><search><creatorcontrib>Balci, Fuat</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Ben Hamed, Suliann</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Boraud, Thomas</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Bouret, Sébastien</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Brochier, Thomas</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Brun, Cédric</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Cohen, Jeremiah Y.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Coutureau, Etienne</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Deffains, Marc</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Doyère, Valérie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Gregoriou, Georgia G.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Heimel, J. Alexander</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Lee, Daeyeol</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Leuthardt, Eric C.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Mainen, Zachary F.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Mathis, Mackenzie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Monosov, Ilya E.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Naudé, Jérémie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Orsborn, Amy L.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Procyk, Emmanuel</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sabatini, Bernardo</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sallet, Jérôme</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sandi, Carmen</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Schall, Jeffrey D.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Soltani, Alireza</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Svoboda, Karel</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Wilson, Charles R.E.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Zimmermann, Jan</creatorcontrib><title>A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish</title><title>Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.)</title><addtitle>Neuron</addtitle><description>The article ‘In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world’ by Kagan et al. triggered a wave of positive mainstream and scientific media coverage as well as a widespread negative reaction from the scientific community. Here, we discuss why this negative reaction is legitimate and must be taken seriously. We raise concerns about the key claim of the article: that it demonstrates that “a single layer of in vitro cortical neurons can self-organize activity to display intelligent and sentient behavior when embodied in a simulated game-world”.</description><subject>Cognitive science</subject><subject>Neuroscience</subject><issn>0896-6273</issn><issn>1097-4199</issn><fulltext>true</fulltext><rsrctype>article</rsrctype><creationdate>2023</creationdate><recordtype>article</recordtype><recordid>eNp9kEtLxDAQgIMouj7-gUiOemidPJomF2GR9QELXvQcsmmqWdpmTbqC_96sVY-e5sE3M8yH0DmBkgAR1-tycNsYhpICZSXQEkDtoRkBVRecKLWPZiCVKASt2RE6TmkNQHilyCE6YkIKxoiaocUcR5c2YUgOjwHbzvg-4dBi17v46oYR-2F0Xedzbh02Q4NT7vrvyg_Y4Mant1N00JouubOfeIJe7hbPtw_F8un-8Xa-LCzndCwIEw2VUBlWifzCqua1FYQx1jJLhZFM2QpWjeRMmZpWoKwUQlhhRCNaMJydoKtp75vp9Cb63sRPHYzXD_Ol3vWAA6Ec5AfJ7OXEbmJ437o06t4nm18xgwvbpGktGVdUSpZRPqE2hpSia_92E9A72XqtJ9l6J1sD1Vl2Hrv4ubBd9a75G_q1m4GbCXDZyYd3USf7ba7x0dlRN8H_f-ELGpqPMQ</recordid><startdate>20230301</startdate><enddate>20230301</enddate><creator>Balci, Fuat</creator><creator>Ben Hamed, Suliann</creator><creator>Boraud, Thomas</creator><creator>Bouret, Sébastien</creator><creator>Brochier, Thomas</creator><creator>Brun, Cédric</creator><creator>Cohen, Jeremiah Y.</creator><creator>Coutureau, Etienne</creator><creator>Deffains, Marc</creator><creator>Doyère, Valérie</creator><creator>Gregoriou, Georgia G.</creator><creator>Heimel, J. Alexander</creator><creator>Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth</creator><creator>Lee, Daeyeol</creator><creator>Leuthardt, Eric C.</creator><creator>Mainen, Zachary F.</creator><creator>Mathis, Mackenzie</creator><creator>Monosov, Ilya E.</creator><creator>Naudé, Jérémie</creator><creator>Orsborn, Amy L.</creator><creator>Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo</creator><creator>Procyk, Emmanuel</creator><creator>Sabatini, Bernardo</creator><creator>Sallet, Jérôme</creator><creator>Sandi, Carmen</creator><creator>Schall, Jeffrey D.</creator><creator>Soltani, Alireza</creator><creator>Svoboda, Karel</creator><creator>Wilson, Charles R.E.</creator><creator>Zimmermann, Jan</creator><general>Elsevier Inc</general><general>Elsevier</general><scope>NPM</scope><scope>AAYXX</scope><scope>CITATION</scope><scope>7X8</scope><scope>1XC</scope><scope>VOOES</scope><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7486-4993</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0057-7929</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5781-6498</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6948-1234</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3851-669X</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7878-0209</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9497-919X</orcidid></search><sort><creationdate>20230301</creationdate><title>A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish</title><author>Balci, Fuat ; Ben Hamed, Suliann ; Boraud, Thomas ; Bouret, Sébastien ; Brochier, Thomas ; Brun, Cédric ; Cohen, Jeremiah Y. ; Coutureau, Etienne ; Deffains, Marc ; Doyère, Valérie ; Gregoriou, Georgia G. ; Heimel, J. Alexander ; Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth ; Lee, Daeyeol ; Leuthardt, Eric C. ; Mainen, Zachary F. ; Mathis, Mackenzie ; Monosov, Ilya E. ; Naudé, Jérémie ; Orsborn, Amy L. ; Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo ; Procyk, Emmanuel ; Sabatini, Bernardo ; Sallet, Jérôme ; Sandi, Carmen ; Schall, Jeffrey D. ; Soltani, Alireza ; Svoboda, Karel ; Wilson, Charles R.E. ; Zimmermann, Jan</author></sort><facets><frbrtype>5</frbrtype><frbrgroupid>cdi_FETCH-LOGICAL-c442t-136d2805a356016b747c61333f3c26a839c50bd8439a72509c8666c6a6d6f0a43</frbrgroupid><rsrctype>articles</rsrctype><prefilter>articles</prefilter><language>eng</language><creationdate>2023</creationdate><topic>Cognitive science</topic><topic>Neuroscience</topic><toplevel>peer_reviewed</toplevel><toplevel>online_resources</toplevel><creatorcontrib>Balci, Fuat</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Ben Hamed, Suliann</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Boraud, Thomas</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Bouret, Sébastien</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Brochier, Thomas</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Brun, Cédric</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Cohen, Jeremiah Y.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Coutureau, Etienne</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Deffains, Marc</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Doyère, Valérie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Gregoriou, Georgia G.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Heimel, J. Alexander</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Lee, Daeyeol</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Leuthardt, Eric C.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Mainen, Zachary F.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Mathis, Mackenzie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Monosov, Ilya E.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Naudé, Jérémie</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Orsborn, Amy L.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Procyk, Emmanuel</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sabatini, Bernardo</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sallet, Jérôme</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Sandi, Carmen</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Schall, Jeffrey D.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Soltani, Alireza</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Svoboda, Karel</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Wilson, Charles R.E.</creatorcontrib><creatorcontrib>Zimmermann, Jan</creatorcontrib><collection>PubMed</collection><collection>CrossRef</collection><collection>MEDLINE - Academic</collection><collection>Hyper Article en Ligne (HAL)</collection><collection>Hyper Article en Ligne (HAL) (Open Access)</collection><jtitle>Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.)</jtitle></facets><delivery><delcategory>Remote Search Resource</delcategory><fulltext>fulltext</fulltext></delivery><addata><au>Balci, Fuat</au><au>Ben Hamed, Suliann</au><au>Boraud, Thomas</au><au>Bouret, Sébastien</au><au>Brochier, Thomas</au><au>Brun, Cédric</au><au>Cohen, Jeremiah Y.</au><au>Coutureau, Etienne</au><au>Deffains, Marc</au><au>Doyère, Valérie</au><au>Gregoriou, Georgia G.</au><au>Heimel, J. Alexander</au><au>Kilavik, Bjørg Elisabeth</au><au>Lee, Daeyeol</au><au>Leuthardt, Eric C.</au><au>Mainen, Zachary F.</au><au>Mathis, Mackenzie</au><au>Monosov, Ilya E.</au><au>Naudé, Jérémie</au><au>Orsborn, Amy L.</au><au>Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo</au><au>Procyk, Emmanuel</au><au>Sabatini, Bernardo</au><au>Sallet, Jérôme</au><au>Sandi, Carmen</au><au>Schall, Jeffrey D.</au><au>Soltani, Alireza</au><au>Svoboda, Karel</au><au>Wilson, Charles R.E.</au><au>Zimmermann, Jan</au><format>journal</format><genre>article</genre><ristype>JOUR</ristype><atitle>A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish</atitle><jtitle>Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.)</jtitle><addtitle>Neuron</addtitle><date>2023-03-01</date><risdate>2023</risdate><volume>111</volume><issue>5</issue><spage>604</spage><epage>605</epage><pages>604-605</pages><issn>0896-6273</issn><eissn>1097-4199</eissn><abstract>The article ‘In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world’ by Kagan et al. triggered a wave of positive mainstream and scientific media coverage as well as a widespread negative reaction from the scientific community. Here, we discuss why this negative reaction is legitimate and must be taken seriously. We raise concerns about the key claim of the article: that it demonstrates that “a single layer of in vitro cortical neurons can self-organize activity to display intelligent and sentient behavior when embodied in a simulated game-world”.</abstract><cop>United States</cop><pub>Elsevier Inc</pub><pmid>36863319</pmid><doi>10.1016/j.neuron.2023.02.009</doi><tpages>2</tpages><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7486-4993</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0057-7929</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5781-6498</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6948-1234</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3851-669X</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7878-0209</orcidid><orcidid>https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9497-919X</orcidid><oa>free_for_read</oa></addata></record> |
| fulltext | fulltext |
| identifier | ISSN: 0896-6273 |
| ispartof | Neuron (Cambridge, Mass.), 2023-03, Vol.111 (5), p.604-605 |
| issn | 0896-6273 1097-4199 |
| language | eng |
| recordid | cdi_hal_primary_oai_HAL_hal_04012408v1 |
| source | Cell Press Free Archives; Elsevier ScienceDirect Journals; Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek - Frei zugängliche E-Journals |
| subjects | Cognitive science Neuroscience |
| title | A response to claims of emergent intelligence and sentience in a dish |
| url | https://sfx.bib-bvb.de/sfx_tum?ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&ctx_enc=info:ofi/enc:UTF-8&ctx_tim=2025-02-21T21%3A35%3A17IST&url_ver=Z39.88-2004&url_ctx_fmt=infofi/fmt:kev:mtx:ctx&rfr_id=info:sid/primo.exlibrisgroup.com:primo3-Article-proquest_hal_p&rft_val_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:journal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=A%20response%20to%20claims%20of%20emergent%20intelligence%20and%20sentience%20in%20a%20dish&rft.jtitle=Neuron%20(Cambridge,%20Mass.)&rft.au=Balci,%20Fuat&rft.date=2023-03-01&rft.volume=111&rft.issue=5&rft.spage=604&rft.epage=605&rft.pages=604-605&rft.issn=0896-6273&rft.eissn=1097-4199&rft_id=info:doi/10.1016/j.neuron.2023.02.009&rft_dat=%3Cproquest_hal_p%3E2783492883%3C/proquest_hal_p%3E%3Curl%3E%3C/url%3E&disable_directlink=true&sfx.directlink=off&sfx.report_link=0&rft_id=info:oai/&rft_pqid=2783492883&rft_id=info:pmid/36863319&rft_els_id=S0896627323001137&rfr_iscdi=true |