Evolutionary dependence of host type and chasmothecial appendage morphology in obligate plant parasites belonging to Erysipheae (powdery mildew, Erysiphaceae)

Evolutionary relationships between the morphological and ecological traits of fungi are poorly understood. The appendages of chasmothecia, which are sexual reproductive organs of Erysiphaceae, are considered to play a crucial role in the overwintering strategies of these fungi on host plants. Previous studies suggested that both the host type and appendage morphology evolved at the same nodes and transitioned from complex appendages on deciduous hosts to simple appendages on herb/evergreen hosts. However, the evolutionary dependence between host type and appendage morphology remains unproven owing to the limited species data used in analyses. To elucidate the evolutionary relationship between host type and appendage morphology, we used phylogenetic comparative methods (PCMs) to investigate the state transition, ancestral state, evolutionary dependence, and contingent evolution within Erysipheae, the largest and most diverse tribe in Erysiphaceae. Our PCMs, based on a comprehensive data set of Erysipheae, revealed that the most ancestral states were deciduous host types and complex appendages. From these ancestral states, convergent evolution toward the herb/evergreen host types and simple appendages occurred multiple times at the same nodes. For the first time in Erysiphaceae, we detected an evolutionary dependence between host type and appendage morphology. This is one of the few examples in which evolutionary dependence between host phenology and morphological traits in plant-parasitic fungi was demonstrated using PCMs. Appendage simplification on herb/evergreen hosts and complications on deciduous hosts can be reasonably explained by the functional advantages of each appendage type in different overwintering strategies. These expected appendage functions can explain approximately 90% of host type and appendage morphology combinations observed in the analyzed taxa. However, our results also highlighted the occurrence of evolutionary shifts that deviate from the expected advantages of each appendage morphology. These seemingly irrational shifts might be interpretable from the flexibility of overwintering strategies and quantification of appendage functions.