Structural Factors Contributing to the Hydrophobic Effect: The Partly Exposed Hydrophobic Minicore in Chymotrypsin Inhibitor 2

The structural basis for the stability of a partly solvent-exposed hydrophobic minicore, formed by the residues Leu51, Val57, and Phe69 in the reactive loop of the serine protease inhibitor chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2), was analyzed from the stability of 17 mutant proteins, in which side chain methylene groups were deleted or rearranged. The mutations destabilize the protein by 0.3-4.8 kcal/mol, an average of 0.6 kcal per removed methylene group. Double mutant cycles show significant interaction between individual pairs of side chains. There is an excellent linear correlation (r = 0.995) between the free energy of unfolding relative to wild type (delta delta GU-F) and the packing density nC (the number of methyl and methylene groups within 6 A of the removed atoms). delta delta GU-F correlates more weakly with changes in solvent-accessible surface area upon mutation. The correlation improves when the change in solvent-accessible surface are upon mutation is separated into distinct contributions from polar atoms that are able to hydrogen bond to solvent (delta AHB) and from nonpolar atoms (delta AHP). There is also a correlation, however, between packing density and changes in surface area. Elsewhere in CI2, delta delta GU-F for mutations in the buried hydrophobic core correlates best with packing density, whereas in the exposed surface of the alpha-helix, the best correlation is with change in surface area.